Ας δούμε κάτι διαφορετικό.
Τι γράφει ο Άγγλος ιστορικός A. J. P. Taylor στο βιβλίο του "The War Lords", όπου εκθέτει τα πορτραίτα των αρχηγών που μετείχαν στον 2οΠΠ. Ποια η συμβολή του Στάλιν, πόσες λάθος εκτιμήσεις έκανε στον πόλεμο. Πόσο στοίχησαν αυτές σε ζωές ρώσων στρατιωτών.
Μερικά χαρακτηριστικά αποσπάσματα:
In the early months of 1941, somebody has calculated, Stalin received no fewer than 76 separate warnings that Germany was about to invade Russia. They came from the American government, from the British government, from Stalin's own secret agents all over Europe and from practical indications of the mobilisation of the German forces. But Stalin said: 'Hitler is going to threaten us, he is going to exact greater concessions from us; but, as long as he has Great Britain to contend with, he will not invade us.'
Stalin continued for most of 1941 to be obsessed with his belief that to be on the offensive was the only answer. It brought upon the Soviet armies greater catastrophes than any other armies have ever known. Between June 1941 and the tailing-offs of the German offensive, which came in October, the Russians lost something like four million dead, and at least two million Russians were made German prisoners-of-war, many of them later being murdered. It was the inexhaustible human resources of Soviet Russia which kept her going. At one time, Halder, the German chief of staff, said: 'We estimated that we should contend with 180 Russian divisions; we have already counted 360.’
Stalin overestimated his successes. In December 1941, he told Eden, who was then visiting Moscow: 'In a few months, I shall have troops to join you in the Far East.' In fact, he was going to have to wait another three years at least before he could envisage sending troops there. The Russian counter-offensive petered out. Both sides prepared for a further offensive. Here again, Stalin misjudged. His great mistake was to insist on trying to disturb the German plans by an offensive of his own. This was the Russian
Russian offensive of March to May 1942 against Kharkov, which was catastrophic and opened the whole of south Russia to German invasion forces. Stalin again refused to allow any kind of retreats and, as a result, most of the Russian armies there were lost.
Stalin was the only war lord of the Second World War who shot his generals for failure in the field. Hitler, of course, shot some generals who conspired against him, but that was something very different.